October 23, 2020
California’s Proposition 21 Could Stifle Multifamily Property Investments

According to a recent report by Marcus & Millichap, California’s Proposition 21 that is on the November ballot could place restrictions on apartment owners and create...

California’s Proposition 21 Could Stifle Multifamily Property Investments

October 21, 2020 | James Sprow | Blue Vault

According to a recent report by Marcus & Millichap, California’s Proposition 21 that is on the November ballot could place restrictions on apartment owners and create disincentives for upkeep and new investment. Apparently, the proponents of this legislation do not understand the basics of economics and the unintended consequences of price controls. Basic economic theory illustrates how price controls produce shortages as supply is constrained below equilibrium with demand. The resulting unintended consequences of government price controls are to create shortages that impact the very citizens the laws are presumed to help. In the case of Proposition 21, placing new restrictions on the ability of apartment owners to raise rents, even to return rents to pre-pandemic levels when the health crisis abates, will lead to less investment in maintaining or upgrading properties, and seriously affect the supply of new units.

From the Marcus and Millichap Special Report:

California initiative set to upend rent control. Proposition 21, which is on the November ballot, introduces a new law surrounding rent control and amends existing legislation. The largest proposed change alters how rents are adjusted during tenant turnover. Under the two existing laws that dictate rent control in the state, operators are free to lift the monthly rent back to the market rate upon a vacancy, often called vacancy decontrol. However, Proposition21 would restrict owners to a 15 percent rise in rents when a new tenant moves in, creating vacancy control. That gain can be realized over three years in any manner that owner chooses, along with any locally permitted increase. After that, rent increases will be dictated by the local rental board.

Unintended consequences in legislation. Properties older than15 years old could fall under new rent control policies enacted at the local level. Without a path to bring rent back to the market rate upon vacancy, the impetus for owners to reinvest capital in these older properties will be eroded over time, particularly as controlled rent falls below those for new properties. Renters will also feel the impact of vacancy control. As operators manage costs without the ability to recoup investment, fewer and lower-quality upgrades will be available. Furthermore, developers will also shy away from cities with vacancy control, elevating the housing shortage in California. Areas where several small municipalities exist side-by-side could see disparate construction and reinvestment.

Health crisis compounds challenges with vacancy control. Lockdowns, particularly those in densely populated areas, have caused significant disruptions in several local apartment markets. San Francisco, for example, recorded a rent decline of 4 percent in the second quarter and another 6 percent decrease in the third quarter. Further erosion is expected through the end of the year and potentially into 2021 depending on the damage done to the local economy, fiscal stimulus and the extent of dispersed working. A resolution to the health crisis could reignite one of the strongest local economies and quickly return apartment demand. Without the ability to reset apartment rents to pre-pandemic conditions, valuations could decline considerably.”

The people who will be affected if Proposition 21 passes are not just the owners of apartments who will suffer declines in property values, but also the people who want to rent apartments closer to their jobs and find that those apartments are not being maintained or upgraded, or not being built at all. Legislation can prevent free markets from functioning efficiently, but legislation cannot repeal the basic principles of economics.

Source: www.marcusmillichap.com/research/special-report/2020/10/california-proposition-21

Recent

ASHFORD SECURITIES EXPANDS TEAM WITH STRATEGIC HIRES

ASHFORD SECURITIES EXPANDS TEAM WITH STRATEGIC HIRES

Ashford Securities LLC strengthens its leadership team with dynamic new talent, signaling exciting developments in its national growth strategy and commitment to financial intermediaries—discover the seasoned professionals driving this next chapter.
Ken Carpenter Promoted to President of Madison Capital Group

Ken Carpenter Promoted to President of Madison Capital Group

"Ken has been an integral part of our leadership team as Chief Investment Officer, and I am confident he will guide the company with the same vision, integrity, and energy that have brought us to where we are today," — Ryan Hanks, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Madison Capital Group.

Most Popular

Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update

Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update

Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update 10-3-2023 Blue Vault wishes to acknowledge and apologize for the delay in publishing some Q2 2023 NTR Individual Performance Pages (IPPs) as well as the full review. We recently added additional reporting metrics to our IPPs, and that, combined with coverage of all share classes and some additional…
Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update

Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update

Blue Vault Q2 2023 Performance Reports Update 9-25-2023 Blue Vault has published the Q2 2023 Nontraded BDC Industry Review as well as Individual Performance Report and Limited Operations pages for the following offerings (newly published pages in bold font): Nontraded REITS American Healthcare REIT Q2 2023 Apollo Realty Income Solutions Q2 2023 (limited operations) Ares…

Explore

Blue Vault Logo
Don’t miss alts news
and educational events

Subscribe Now
Marketing Intent: Get 20+ experts for your marketing budget